Forget Cape Cod, This Lovely East Coast Town Is A Remote Peninsula With Pretty Beaches And Historic Charm
Everybody loves Cape Cod. You can't really go wrong with the Massachusetts peninsula that's full of scenic and historic beach towns. Don't overlook Martha's Vineyard, though. Even more remote, this island is only accessible by ferry or plane, making it harder to get to. It's worth the effort, though; its beautiful beaches and gorgeous little towns are among the best places you'll ever vacation.
The six towns on Martha's Vineyard all have their charm, but there's something special about Aquinnah. Formerly known as Gay Head, this town sits on its own peninsula on the western side of the island; it's the westernmost town on Martha's Vineyard and also home to two of the island's most popular tourist attractions, the cliffs and lighthouse that share the town's name. It's the smallest of the six towns, but the closest to those two heavily photographed sites.
If you do consider staying in Aquinnah during your Vineyard vacation, make note that there are no hotels in the town. If you're going to stay here, you'll have to rent a home. That might complicate your plans a little, but there's a big upside to renting here: it gets you access to all three of Aquinnah's beaches, including the one that's reserved for residents and renters, provided you purchase the required Philbin Beach parking permit or walk-on pass.
Some of the prettiest beaches in New England
Obviously, you can't visit Martha's Vineyard without hitting the beach. Fortunately, at Aquinnah's three beaches you can partake in a range of aquatic activities, from the strenuous to the leisurely, while also catching unparalleled sunsets and gazing at its beloved natural wonder. It's on Aquinnah's beaches where you most understand why former resident Michael J. Fox said he was happiest at this vacation destination.
Moshup Beach is named after the legendary hero of the Wampanoag, Moshup, who is said to have turned the clay red with the blood of the whales he killed for his dinner, per Atlas Obscura. It's a half-mile beach that's open to the public and sits beneath the Aquinnah Cliffs. Moshup is popular for skimboarding and swimming, and anglers can expect to catch bluefish and bass. Part of it has also been an unofficial, undesignated nude beach for many years — it's not technically legal, but apparently few people are hassled when they go au naturel here. You're free to walk along the shore, but don't take any clay, and don't disturb the cliffs; they're protected by the Aquinnah Wampanoag Tribe.
Also open to the public is Lobsterville Beach. Hit the water with a mask and snorkel, keep an eye out for birds, or go for a walk on its 2-mile shoreline. True to its name, this was once a highly fruitful lobster fishing site. Aquinnah's third beach, Philbin, is not open to the public, but anybody renting a property in the town can access it. With its rocky shore and more turbulent waters, it's become known for surfing, so don't leave your board at home if you plan on renting a house in Aquinnah.
Historic charm and scenic beauty
It's well known that Martha's Vineyard perfectly captures the charm of an English village, but the historic charm you'll find in Aquinnah is both older and more local. It starts with the cliffs. These 100-foot-tall clay cliffs have been a sacred site for the Wampanoag tribe for centuries; they were the home of the godlike giant Moshup, whose titanic actions, they believe, created the islands around Martha's Vineyard. The cliffs' mixture of clay and sand gives them a rainbow-like coloration, and that jaunty appearance made the English who settled here give them the name Gay Head Cliffs, after the original meaning of the word. The scenic lighthouse here is called Gay Head Lighthouse and is also known as Aquinnah Lighthouse. Originally built in 1799, with the current structure dating to 1856, it's open seasonally. Massachusetts is known for its jaw-dropping lighthouses in Cape Cod and elsewhere on the shore, and, like the cliffs, Aquinnah's is one of the most popular attractions on Martha's Vineyard.
The cliffs and lighthouse are both part of the Aquinnah Circle Cultural District. Take time to explore here and learn more about the region's history and the Wampanoag people at the Aquinnah Cultural Center, a museum about the tribe. You can find Indigenous-owned shops here, too.
If you're a movie buff, you might be excited to hear that Aquinnah was one of several Martha's Vineyard towns Steven Spielberg's "Jaws" was shot in. You can see the Aquinnah Lighthouse and clay cliffs in the background of select shots of the original modern blockbuster, and the "Amity Island Welcomes You" sign from the movie was a prop temporarily erected in Aquinnah. So it's not just a vital part of Wampanoag history, but Hollywood's history, too.